Theorbitalmotionoftheouterfivesseemsrigorouslystableandquitereguroverthistime-span(seealsoSection5).
3.2Time–frequencymaps
Althoughthearymotionexhibitsverylong-termstabilitydefinedasthenon-existenceofcloseencounterevents,thechaoticnatureofarydynamicscanchangetheosciltoryperiodandamplitudeofaryorbitalmotiongraduallyoversuchlongtime-spans.Evensuchslightfluctuationsoforbitalvariationinthefrequencydomain,particurlyinthecaseofEarth,canpotentiallyhaveasignificanteffectonitssurfaceclimatesystemthroughsorinsotionvariation(cf.Berger1988).
Togiveanoverviewofthelong-termchangeinperiodicityinaryorbitalmotion,weperformedmanyfastFouriertransformations(FFTs)alongthetimeaxis,andsuperposedtheresultingperiodgramstodrawtwo-dimensionaltime–frequencymaps.Thespecificapproachtodrawingthesetime–frequencymapsinthispaperisverysimple–muchsimplerthanthewaveletanalysisorskar's(1990,1993)frequencyanalysis.
Dividethelow-passfilteredorbitaldataintomanyfragmentsofthesamelenh.Thelenhofeachdatasegmentshouldbeamultipleof2inordertoapplytheFFT.
Eachfragmentofthedatahasargeoverppingpart:forexample,whentheithdatabeginsfromt=tiandendsatt=ti T,thenextdatasegmentrangesfromti δT≤ti δT T,whereδT?T.WecontinuethisdivisionuntilwereachacertainnumberNbywhichtn Treachesthetotalintegrationlenh.
WeapplyanFFTtoeachofthedatafragments,andobtainnfrequencydiagrams.
Ineachfrequencydiagramobtainedabove,thestrenhofperiodicitycanberepcedbyagrey-scale(orcolour)chart.
Weperformtherepcement,andconnectallthegrey-scale(orcolour)chartsintoonegraphforeachintegration.Thehorizontaxisofthesenewgraphsshouldbethetime,i.e.thestartingtimesofeachfragmentofdata(ti,wherei=1,…,n).Theverticaxisrepresentstheperiod(orfrequency)oftheosciltionoforbitalelements.
WehaveadoptedanFFTbecauseofitsoverwhelmingspeed,sincetheamountofnumericaldatatobedposedintofrequencponentsisterriblyhuge(severaltensofGbytes).
Atypicalexampleofthetime–frequencymapcreatedbytheaboveproceduresisshowninagrey-scalediagramasFig.5,whichshowsthevariationofperiodicityintheentricityandinclinationofEarthinN 2integration.InFig.5,thedarkareashowsthatatthetimeindicatedbythevalueontheabscissa,theperiodicityindicatedbytheordinateisstrongerthaninthelighterareaaroundit.WecanrecognizefromthismapthattheperiodicityoftheentricityandinclinationofEarthonlychangesslightlyovertheentireperiodcoveredbytheN 2integration.Thisnearlyregurtrendisqualitativelythesameinotherintegrationsandforothers,althoughtypicalfrequenciesdifferbyandelementbyelement.
4.2Long-termexchangeoforbitalenergyandangurmomentum
Wecalcuteverylong-periodicvariationandexchangeofaryorbitalenergyandangurmomentumusingfilteredDeunayelementsL,G,H.GandHareequivalenttothearyorbitangurmomentumanditsverticaponentperunitmass.LisretedtothearyorbitalenergyEperunitmassasE=?μ22L2.Ifthesystemipletelylinear,theorbitalenergyandtheangurmomentumineachfrequencybinmustbeconstant.Non-linearityinthearysystemcancauseanexchangeofenergyandangurmomentuminthefrequencydomain.Theamplitudeofthelowest-frequencyosciltionshouldincreaseifthesystemisunstableandbreaksdowngradually.However,suchasymptomofinstabilityisnotprominentinourlong-termintegrations.
InFig.7,thetotalorbitalenergyandangurmomentumofthefourinnersandallninesareshownforintegrationN 2.Theupperthreepanelsshowthelong-periodicvariationoftotalenergy(denotedasE-E0),totangurmomentum(G-G0),andtheverticaponent(H-H0)oftheinnerfourscalcutedfromthelow-passfilteredDeunayelements.E0,G0,H0denotetheinitialvaluesofeachquantity.Theabsolutedifferencefromtheinitialvaluesisplottedinthepanels.ThelowerthreepanelsineachfigureshowE-E0,G-G0andH-H0ofthetotalofnines.Thefluctuationshowninthelowerpanelsisvirtuallyentirelyaresultofthemassivejovians.
Comparingthevariationsofenergyandangurmomentumoftheinnerfoursandallnines,itisapparentthattheamplitudesofthoseoftheinnersaremuchsmallerthanthoseofallnines:theamplitudesoftheouterfivesaremuchrgerthanthoseoftheinners.Thisdoesnotmeanthattheinnerterrestrirysubsystemismorestablethantheouterone:thisissimplyaresultoftheretivesmallnessofthemassesofthefourterrestrialparedwiththoseoftheouterjovians.Anotherthingwenoticeisthattheinnerarysubsystemmaybeunstablemorerapidlythantheouteronebecauseofitsshorterorbitaltime-scales.Thiscanbeseeninthepanelsdenotedasinner4inFig.7wherethelonger-periodicandirregurosciltionsaremoreapparentthaninthepanelsdenotedastotal9.Actually,thefluctuationsintheinner4panelsaretoargeextentasaresultoftheorbitalvariationoftheMercury.However,wecannotneglectthecontributionfromotherterrestrials,aswewillseeinsubsequentsections.
4.4Long-termcouplingofseveralneighbouringpairs
Letusseesomeindividualvariationsofaryorbitalenergyandangurmomentumexpressedbythelow-passfilteredDeunayelements.Figs10and11showlong-termevolutionoftheorbitalenergyofeachandtheangurmomentuminN 1andN?2integrations.Wenoticethatsomesformapparentpairsintermsoforbitalenergyandangurmomentumexchange.Inparticur,VenusandEarthmakeatypicalpair.Inthefigures,theyshownegativecorretionsinexchangeofenergyandpositivecorretionsinexchangeofangurmomentuhepositivecorretioninexchangeofangurmomentummeansthatthetwosaresimultaneouslyundercertainlong-termperturbations.CandidatesforperturbersareJupiterandSaturn.AlsoinFig.11,wecanseethatMarsshowsapositivecorretionintheangurmomentumvariationtotheVenus–EarthsystemrcuryexhibitscertainnegativecorretionsintheangurmomentumversustheVenus–Earthsystem,whichseemstobeareactioncausedbytheconservationofangurmomentumintheterrestrirysubsystem.
ItisnotclearatthemomentwhytheVenus–Earthpairexhibitsanegativecorretioninenergyexchangeandapositivecorretioninangurmomentumexchange.Wemaypossiblyexpinthisthroughobservingthegeneralfactthattherearenosecurtermsinarysemimajoraxesuptosecond-orderperturbationtheories(cf.BrouwerClemence1961;BalettiPuco1998).Thismeansthatthearyorbitalenergy(whichisdirectlyretedtothesemimajoraxisa)mightbemuchlessaffectedbyperturbingsthanistheangurmomentumexchange(whichretestoe).Hence,theentricitiesofVenusandEarthcanbedisturbedeasilybyJupiterandSaturn,whichresultsinapositivecorretionintheangurmomentumexchange.Ontheotherhand,thesemimajoraxesofVenusandEartharelesslikelytobedisturbedbythejovians.ThustheenergyexchangemaybelimitedonlywithintheVenus–Earthpair,whichresultsinanegativecorretionintheexchangeoforbitalenergyinthepair.
Asfortheouterjovianarysubsystem,Jupiter–SaturnandUranus–Neptuneseemtomakedynamicalpairs.However,thestrenhoftheircouplingisnotasstronparedwiththatoftheVenus–Earthpair.
5±5×1010-yrintegrationsofouteraryorbits
Sincethejovianarymassesaremuchrgerthantheterrestrirymasses,wetreatthejovianarysystemasanindependentarysystemintermsofthestudyofitsdynamicalstability.Hence,weaddedacoupleoftrialintegrationsthatspan±5×1010yr,includingonlytheouterfives(thefourjoviansplusPluto).Theresultsexhibittherigorousstabilityoftheouterarysystemoverthislongtime-span.Orbitalconfigurations(Fig.12),andvariationofentricitiesandinclinations(Fig.13)showthisverylong-termstabilityoftheouterfivesinboththetimeandthefrequencydomains.Althoughwedonotshowmapshere,thetypicalfrequencyoftheorbitalosciltionofPlutoandtheotheroutersisalmostconstantduringtheseverylong-termintegrationperiods,whichisdemonstratedinthetime–frequencymapsonourwebpage.
Inthesetwointegrations,theretivenumericalerrorinthetotalenergywas~10?6andthatofthetotangurmomentumwas~10?10.
5.1ResonancesintheNeptune–Plutosystem
Kino**aNakai(1996)integratedtheouterfivearyorbitsover±5.5×109yr.TheyfoundthatfourmajorresonancesbetweenNeptuneandPlutoaremaintainedduringthewholeintegrationperiod,andthattheresonancesmaybethemaincausesofthestabilityoftheorbitofPluto.Themajorfourresonancesfoundinpreviousresearchareasfollows.Inthefollowingdescription,λdenotesthemeanlongitude,Ωisthelongitudeoftheascendingnodeand?isthelongitudeofperihelion.SubscriptsPandNdenotePlutoandNeptune.
MeanmotionresonancebetweenNeptuneandPluto(3:2).Thecriticargumentθ1=3λP?2λN??Plibratesaround180°withanamplitudeofabout80°andalibrationperiodofabout2×104yr.
TheargumentofperihelionofPlutoωP=θ2=?P?ΩPlibratesaround90°withaperiodofabout3.8×106yr.ThedominantperiodicvariationsoftheentricityandinclinationofPlutoaresynchronizedwiththelibrationofitsargumentofperihelion.ThisisanticipatedinthesecurperturbationtheoryconstructedbyKozai(1962).
ThelongitudeofthenodeofPlutoreferredtothelongitudeofthenodeofNeptune,θ3=ΩP?ΩN,circutesandtheperiodofthiscircutionisequaltotheperiodofθ2libration.Whenθ3beszero,i.e.thelongitudesofascendingnodesofNeptuneandPlutooverp,theinclinationofPlutobesmaximum,theentricitybesminimumandtheargumentofperihelionbes90°.Whenθ3bes180°,theinclinationofPlutobesminimum,theentricitybesmaximumandtheargumentofperihelionbes90°again.WilliamsBenson(1971)anticipatedthistypeofresonance,terconfirmedbyMini,NobiliCarpino(1989).
Anargumentθ4=?P??N 3(ΩP?ΩN)libratesaround180°withalongperiod,~5.7×108yr.
Inournumericalintegrations,theresonances(i)–(iii)arewellmaintained,andvariationofthecriticargumentsθ1,θ2,θ3remainsimirduringthewholeintegrationperiod(Figs14–16).However,thefourthresonance(iv)appearstobedifferent:thecriticargumentθ4alternateslibrationandcircutionovera1010-yrtime-scale(Fig.17).ThisisaninterestingfactthatKino**aNakai's(1995,1996)shorterintegrationswerenotabletodisclose.
6Discussion
Whatkindofdynamicalmechanismmaintainsthislong-termstabilityofthearysystem?Wecanimmediatelythinkoftwomajorfeaturesthatmayberesponsibleforthelong-termstability.First,thereseemtobenosignificantlower-orderresonances(meanmotionandsecur)betweenanypairamongthenines.JupiterandSaturnareclosetoa5:2meanmotionresonance(thefamous‘greatinequality’),butnotjustintheresonancezone.Higher-orderresonancesmaycausethechaoticnatureofthearydynamicalmotion,buttheyarenotsostrongastodestroythestablearymotionwithinthelifetimeoftherealSorsystem.Thesecondfeature,whichwethinkismoreimportantforthelong-termstabilityofourarysystem,isthedifferenceindynamicaldistancebetweenterrestriandjovianarysubsystems(ItoTanikawa1999,2001).WhenwemeasurearyseparationsbythemutualHillradii(R_),separationsamongterrestrialsaregreaterthan26RH,whereasthoseamongjoviansarelessthan14RH.Thisdifferenceisdirectlyretedtothedifferencebetweendynamicalfeaturesofterrestriandjovians.Terrestrialshavesmallermasses,shorterorbitalperiodsandwiderdynamicalseparation.Theyarestronglyperturbedbyjoviansthathavergermasses,longerorbitalperiodsandnarrowerdynamicalseparation.Joviansarenotperturbedbyanyothermassivebodies.
Thepresentterrestrirysystemisstillbeingdisturbedbythemassivejovians.However,thewideseparationandmutualinteractionamongtheterrestrialsrendersthedisturbanceineffective;thedegreeofdisturbancebyjoviansisO(eJ)(orderofmagnitudeoftheentricityofJupiter),sincethedisturbancecausedbyjoviansisaforcedosciltionhavinganamplitudeofO(eJ).Heighteningofentricity,forexampleO(eJ)~0.05,isfarfromsufficienttoprovokeinstabilityintheterrestrialshavingsuchawideseparationas26RH.Thusweassumethatthepresentwidedynamicalseparationamongterrestrials(amp;;26RH)isprobablyoneofthemostsignificantconditionsformaintainingthestabilityofthearysystemovera109-yrtime-span.Ourdetailedanalysisoftheretionshipbetweendynamicaldistancebetweensandtheinstabilitytime-scaleofSorsystemarymotionisnowon-going.
AlthoughournumericalintegrationsspanthelifetimeoftheSorsystem,thenumberofintegrationsisfarfromsufficienttofilltheinitialphasespace.Itisnecessarytoperformmoreandmorenumericalintegrationstoconfirmandexamineindetailthelong-termstabilityofourarydynamics.
——以上文段引自Ito,T.amp;Tanikawa,K.Long-termintegrationsandstabilityofaryorbitsinourSorSyste.R.Astron.Soc.336,483–500(2002)
这只是作者君参考的一篇文章,关于太阳系的稳定性。
还有其他论文,不过也都是英文的,相关课题的中文文献很少,那些论文下载一篇要九美元(《Nature》真是暴利),作者君写这篇文章的时候已经回家,不在检测中心,所以没有数据库的使用权,下不起,就不贴上来了。