作者君在作品相关中已经解释过这个问题,并在此列出相关参考文献中的一篇开源论文。
以下是文章内容:
Long-termintegrationsandstabilityofaryorbitsinourSorsystem
Abstract
Wepresenttheresultsofverylong-termnumericalintegrationsofaryorbitalmotionsover109-yrtime-spansincludingallnines.Aquickinspectionofournumericaldatashowsthatthearymotion,atleastinoursimpledynamicalmodel,seemstobequitestableevenoverthisverylongtime-span.Acloserlookatthelowest-frequencyosciltionsusingalow-passfiltershowsusthepotentiallydiffusivecharacterofterrestrirymotion,especiallythatofMercury.ThebehaviouroftheentricityofMercuryinourintegrationsisqualitativelysimirtotheresultsfromJacquesskar'ssecurperturbationtheory(e.g.emax~0.35over~±4Gyr).However,therearenoapparentsecurincreasesofentricityorinclinationinanyorbitalelementsofthes,whichmayberevealedbystilllonger-termnumericalintegrations.Wehavealsoperformedacoupleoftrialintegrationsincludingmotionsoftheouterfivesoverthedurationof±5×1010yr.TheresultindicatesthatthethreemajorresonancesintheNeptune–Plutosystemhavebeenmaintainedoverthe1011-yrtime-span.
1Introduction
1.1Definitionoftheproblem
ThequestionofthestabilityofourSorsystemhasbeendebatedoverseveralhundredyears,sincetheeraofNewton.Theproblemhasattractedmanyfamousmathematiciansovertheyearsandhaspyedacentralroleinthedevelopmentofnon-lineardynamicsandchaostheory.However,wedonotyethaveadefiniteanswertothequestionofwhetherourSorsystemisstableornot.Thisispartlyaresultofthefactthatthedefinitionoftheterm‘stability’isvaguewhenitisusedinretiontotheproblemofarymotionintheSorsystem.Actuallyitisnoteasytogiveaclear,rigorousandphysicallymeaningfuldefinitionofthestabilityofourSorsystem.
Amongmanydefinitionsofstability,hereweadopttheHilldefinition(Gdman1993):actuallythisisnotadefinitionofstability,butofinstability.Wedefineasystemasbingunstablewhenacloseencounterurssomewhereinthesystem,startingfromacertaininitialconfiguration(Chambers,Wetherilmp;amp;Boss1996;ItoTanikawa1999).AsystemisdefinedasexperiencingacloseencounterwhentwobodiesapproachoneanotherwithinanareaofthergerHillradius.Otherwisethesystemisdefinedasbeingstable.HenceforwardwestatethatourarysystemisdynamicallystableifnocloseencounterhappensduringtheageofourSorsystem,about±5Gyr.Incidentally,thisdefinitionmayberepcedbyoneinwhichanurrenceofanyorbitalcrossingbetweeneitherofapairofstakespce.Thisisbecauseweknowfromexperiencethatanorbitalcrossingisverylikelytoleadtoacloseencounterinaryandprotoarysystems(Yoshinaga,KokuboMakino1999).OfcoursethisstatementcannotbesimplyappliedtosystemswithstableorbitalresonancessuchastheNeptune–Plutosystem.
1.2Previousstudiesandaimsofthisresearch
Inadditiontothevaguenessoftheconceptofstability,thesinourSorsystemshowacharactertypicalofdynamicalchaos(SussmanWisdom1988,1992).Thecauseofthischaoticbehaviourisnowpartlyunderstoodasbeingaresultofresonanceoverpping(MurrayHolman1999;Lecar,FranklinHolman2001).However,itwouldrequireintegratingoveranensembleofarysystemsincludingallninesforaperiodcoveringseveral10Gyrtothoroughlyunderstandthelong-termevolutionofaryorbits,sincechaoticdynamicalsystemsarecharacterizedbytheirstrongdependenceoninitialconditions.
Fromthatpointofview,manyofthepreviouslong-termnumericalintegrationsincludedonlytheouterfives(SussmanWisdom1988;Kino**aNakai1996).Thisisbecausetheorbitalperiodsoftheoutersaresomuchlongerthanthoseoftheinnerfoursthatitismucheasiertofollowthesystemforagivenintegrationperiod.Atpresent,thelongestnumericalintegrationspublishedinjournalsarethoseofDuncanLissauer(1998).Althoughtheirmaintargetwastheeffectofpost-main-sequencesormasslossonthestabilityofaryorbits,theyperformedmanyintegrationscoveringupto~1011yroftheorbitalmotionsofthefourjovians.TheinitialorbitalelementsandmassesofsarethesameasthoseofourSorsysteminDuncanLissauer'spaper,buttheydecreasethemassoftheSungraduallyintheirnumericalexperiments.Thisisbecausetheyconsidertheeffectofpost-main-sequencesormasslossinthepaper.Consequently,theyfoundthatthecrossingtime-scaleofaryorbits,whichcanbeatypicalindicatoroftheinstabilitytime-scale,isquitesensitivetotherateofmassdecreaseoftheSun.WhenthemassoftheSunisclosetoitspresentvalue,thejoviansremainstableover1010yr,orperhapslonger.DuncanLissaueralsoperformedfoursimirexperimentsontheorbitalmotionofsevens(VenustoNeptune),whichcoveraspanof~109yr.Theirexperimentsonthesevensarenotyeprehensive,butitseemsthattheterrestrialsalsoremainstableduringtheintegrationperiod,maintainingalmostregurosciltions.
Ontheotherhand,inhisuratesemi-analyticalsecurperturbationtheory(skar1988),skarfindsthatrgeandirregurvariationscanappearintheentricitiesandinclinationsoftheterrestrials,especiallyofMercuryandMarsonatime-scaleofseveral109yr(skar1996).Theresultsofskar'ssecurperturbationtheoryshouldbeconfirmedandinvestigatedbyfullynumericalintegrations.
Inthispaperwepresentpreliminaryresultsofsixlong-termnumericalintegrationsonallninearyorbits,coveringaspanofseveral109yr,andoftwootherintegrationscoveringaspanof±5×1010yr.Thetotalepsedtimeforallintegrationsismorethan5yr,usingseveraldedicatedPCsandworkstations.Oneofthefundamentalconclusionsofourlong-termintegrationsisthatSorsystemarymotionseemstobestableintermsoftheHillstabilitymentionedabove,atleastoveratime-spanof±4Gyr.Actually,inournumericalintegrationsthesystemwasfarmorestablethanwhatisdefinedbytheHillstabilitycriterion:notonlydidnocloseencounterhappenduringtheintegrationperiod,butalsoallthearyorbitalelementshavebeenconfinedinanarrowregionbothintimeandfrequencydomain,thougharymotionsarestochastic.Sincethepurposeofthispaperistoexhibitandoverviewtheresultsofourlong-termnumericalintegrations,weshowtypicalexamplefiguresasevidenceoftheverylong-termstabilityofSorsystemarymotion.Forreaderswhohavemorespecificanddeeperinterestsinournumericalresults,wehavepreparedawebpage(ess),whereweshowraworbitalelements,theirlow-passfilteredresults,variationofDeunayelementsandangurmomentumdeficit,andresultsofoursimpletime–frequencyanalysisonallofourintegrations.
InSection2webrieflyexpinourdynamicalmodel,numericalmethodandinitialconditionsusedinourintegrations.Section3isdevotedtoadescriptionofthequickresultsofthenumericalintegrations.Verylong-termstabilityofSorsystemarymotionisapparentbothinarypositionsandorbitalelements.Aroughestimationofnumericalerrorsisalsogiven.Section4goesontoadiscussionofthelongest-termvariationofaryorbitsusingalow-passfilterandincludesadiscussionofangurmomentumdeficit.InSection5,wepresentasetofnumericalintegrationsfortheouterfivesthatspans±5×1010yr.InSection6wealsodiscussthelong-termstabilityofthearymotionanditspossiblecause.
2Descriptionofthenumericalintegrations
(本部分涉及比较复杂的积分计算,作者君就不贴上来了,贴上来了起点也不一定能成功显示。)
2.3Numericalmethod
Weutilizeasecond-orderWisdom–Holmansymplecticmapasourmainintegrationmethod(WisdomHolman1991;Kino**a,YoshidaNakai1991)withaspecialstart-upproceduretoreducethetruncationerrorofanglevariables,‘warmstart’(SahaTremaine1992,1994).
Thestepsizeforthenumericalintegrationsis8dthroughoutallintegrationsofthenines(N±1,2,3),whichisabout111oftheorbitalperiodoftheinnermost(Mercury).Asforthedeterminationofstepsize,wepartlyfollowthepreviousnumericalintegrationofallninesinSussmanWisdom(1988,7.2d)andSahaTremaine(1994,22532d).Weroundedthedecimalpartofthetheirstepsizesto8tomakethestepsizeamultipleof2inordertoreducetheumutionofround-offerrorinthputationprocesses.Inretiontothis,WisdomHolman(1991)performednumericalintegrationsoftheouterfivearyorbitsusingthesymplecticmapwithastepsizeof400d,110.83oftheorbitalperiodofJupiter.Theirresultseemstobeurateenough,whichpartlyjustifiesourmethodofdeterminingthestepsize.However,sincetheentricityofJupiter(~0.05)ismuchsmallerthanthatofMercury(~0.2),weneedsomecarewhenwparetheseintegrationssimplyintermsofstepsizes.
Intheintegrationoftheouterfives(F±),wefixedthestepsizeat400d.
WeadoptGauss'fandgfunctionsinthesymplecticmaptogetherwiththethird-orderHalleymethod(Danby1992)asasolverforKeplerequations.ThenumberofmaximumiterationswesetinHalley'smethodis15,buttheyneverreachedthemaximuminanyofourintegrations.
Theintervalofthedataoutputis200000d(~547yr)forthecalcutionsofallnines(N±1,2,3),andabout8000000d(~21903yr)fortheintegrationoftheouterfives(F±).
Althoughnooutputfilteringwasdonewhenthenumericalintegrationswereinprocess,weappliedalow-passfiltertotheraworbitaldataafterwehapletedallthecalcutions.SeeSection4.1formoredetail.
2.4Errorestimation
2.4.1Retiveerrorsintotalenergyandangurmomentum
ordingtooneofthebasicpropertiesofsymplecticintegrators,whichconservethephysicallyconservativequantitieswell(totalorbitalenergyandangurmomentum),ourlong-termnumericalintegrationsseemtohavebeenperformedwithverysmallerrors.Theaveragedretiveerrorsoftotalenergy(~10?9)andoftotangurmomentum(~10?11)haveremainednearlyconstantthroughouttheintegrationperiod(Fig.1).Thespecialstartupprocedure,warmstart,wouldhavereducedtheaveragedretiveerrorintotalenergybyaboutoneorderofmagnitudeormore.
RetivenumericalerrorofthetotangurmomentumδAA0andthetotalenergyδEE0inournumericalintegrationsN±1,2,3,whereδEandδAaretheabsolutechangeofthetotalenergyandtotangurmomentum,respectively,andE0andA0aretheirinitialvalues.ThehorizontalunitisGyr.
Notethatdifferentoperatingsystems,differentmathematicallibraries,anddifferenthardwarearchitecturesresultindifferentnumericalerrors,throughthevariationsinround-offerrorhandlingandnumericalgorithms.IntheupperpanelofFig.1,wecanrecognizethissituationinthesecurnumericalerrorinthetotangurmomentum,whichshouldberigorouslypreserveduptomachine-εprecision.
2.4.2Errorinarylongitudes
SincethesymplecticmapspreservetotalenergyandtotangurmomentumofN-bodydynamicalsystemsinherentlywell,thedegreeoftheirpreservationmaynotbeagoodmeasureoftheuracyofnumericalintegrations,especiallyasameasureofthepositionalerrorofs,i.e.theerrorinarylongitudes.Toestimatethenumericalerrorinthearylongitudes,weperformedthefollowingprocedures.Wparedtheresultofourmainlong-termintegrationswithsometestintegrations,whichspanmuchshorterperiodsbutwithmuchhigheruracythanthemainintegrations.Forthispurpose,weperformedamuchmoreurateintegrationwithastepsizeof0.125d(164ofthemainintegrations)spanning3×105yr,startingwiththesameinitialconditionsasintheN?1integration.Weconsiderthatthistestintegrationprovidesuswitha‘pseudo-true’solutionofaryorbitalevolution.Next,wparethetestintegrationwiththemainintegration,N?1.Fortheperiodof3×105yr,weseeadifferenceinmeananomaliesoftheEarthbetweenthetwointegrationsof~0.52°(inthecaseoftheN?1integration).Thisdifferencecanbeextrapotedtothevalue~8700°,about25rotationsofEarthafter5Gyr,sincetheerroroflongitudesincreaseslinearlywithtimeinthesymplecticmap.Simirly,thelongitudeerrorofPlutocanbeestimatedas~12°.ThisvalueforPlutoismuchbetterthantheresultinKino**aNakai(1996)wherethedifferenceisestimatedas~60°.
3Numericalresults–I.Gnceattherawdata
Inthissectionwebrieflyreviewthelong-termstabilityofaryorbitalmotionthroughsomesnapshotsofrawnumericaldata.Theorbitalmotionofsindicateslong-termstabilityinallofournumericalintegrations:noorbitalcrossingsnorcloseencountersbetweenanypairofstookpce.
3.1Generaldescriptionofthestabilityofaryorbits
First,webrieflylookatthegeneralcharacterofthelong-termstabilityofaryorbits.Ourinterestherefocusesparticurlyontheinnerfourterrestrialsforwhichtheorbitaltime-scalesaremuchshorterthanthoseoftheouterfives.AswecanseeclearlyfromthepnarorbitalconfigurationsshowninFigs2and3,orbitalpositionsoftheterrestrialsdifferlittlebetweentheinitiandfinalpartofeachnumericalintegration,whichspansseveralGyr.Thesolidlinesdenotingthepresentorbitsofthesliealmostwithintheswarmofdotseveninthefinalpartofintegrations(b)and(d).Thisindicatesthatthroughouttheentireintegrationperiodthealmostregurvariationsofaryorbitalmotionremainnearlythesameastheyareatpresent.
Verticalviewofthefourinneraryorbits(fromthez-axisdirection)attheinitiandfinalpartsoftheintegrationsN±1.Theaxesunitsareau.Thexy-pneissettotheinvariantpneofSorsystemtotangurmomentum.(a)TheinitialpartofN 1(t=0to0.0547×109yr).(b)ThefinalpartofN 1(t=4.9339×108to4.9886×109yr).(c)TheinitialpartofN?1(t=0to?0.0547×109yr).(d)ThefinalpartofN?1(t=?3.9180×109to?3.9727×109yr).Ineachpanel,atotalof23684pointsareplottedwithanintervalofabout2190yrover5.47×107yr.Solidlinesineachpaneldenotethepresentorbitsofthefourterrestrials(takenfromDE245).
ThevariationofentricitiesandorbitalinclinationsfortheinnerfoursintheinitiandfinalpartoftheintegrationN 1isshowninFig.4.Asexpected,thecharacterofthevariationofaryorbitalelementsdoesnotdiffersignificantlybetweentheinitiandfinalpartofeachintegration,atleastforVenus,EarthandMars.TheelementsofMercury,especiallyitsentricity,seemtochangetoasignificantextent.Thisispartlybecausetheorbitaltime-scaleoftheistheshortestofallthes,whichleadstoamorerapidorbitalevolutionthanothers;theinnermostmaybenearesttoinstability.Thisresultappearstobeinsomeagreementwithskar's(1994,1996)expectationsthatrgeandirregurvariationsappearintheentricitiesandinclinationsofMercuryonatime-scaleofseveral109yr.However,theeffectofthepossibleinstabilityoftheorbitofMercurymaynotfatallyaffecttheglobalstabilityofthewholearysystemowingtothesmallmassofMercury.Wewillmentionbrieflythelong-termorbitalevolutionofMercuryterinSection4usinglow-passfilteredorbitalelements.